The first homemade pumpkin pie of the season
Photo: Chronica Domus
When I bid adieu to England and moved to America in the early 1990's, I had no idea what pumpkin pie was. I imagined it was a savory concoction akin to a plump pork pie.
England's famous pork pies
I soon learned that it was not a pie at all, but rather a tart. At least it was according to my cultural point of reference (a pie, as I understood it at the time, possessed a pastry top and bottom, a tart just a bottom). I was also intrigued to discover that pumpkin
tart pie was not at all savory as one might expect when eating squash. In fact, the delectably sweet and custard-like filling was reminiscent of a childhood favorite dessert, the mysteriously named
Gypsy Tart, dished out as part of one's school dinners. Ah, what fond memories I have of woofing slices of that down the hatch! I could have given Oliver Twist a run for his money I can assure you.
Gypsy Tart, possibly my fondest memory of school dinners
and not too dissimilar in texture to pumpkin tart pie
My inaugural slice of velvety pumpkin
tart pie was served to me at my mother-in-law's house during my very first Thanksgiving feast. My American husband explained that it was his favorite pie, and a staple at practically every Thanksgiving table in the country. It is what Christmas pudding is to a British Christmas. He was certainly right on that score. Now that I consider myself a seasoned pumpkin
tart pie eater, I would go as far as declaring it the quintessential American pie, even more so than apple. I know of no other country that features this particular pie flavoring as part of its national cuisine.
I soon added pumpkin
tart pie to
my baking repertoire and make at least two of them for our
annual Thanksgiving dinner for waifs and strays. Being a curious cook, and one that enjoys using fresh local ingredients and cooking from scratch, I was quite taken aback to discover that most recipes I stumbled across called for canned pumpkin. Well, I was having none of that I can tell you! No, I was determined to make my very own filling, the old-fashioned way, just as it was done by the early eighteenth century New England cooks to celebrate their regional holiday. I'll admit, that ridiculous notion lasted all but a few time-consuming and pointless attempts. For, you see, fiddling about with rock-hard pumpkins, slimy and slippery orange flesh, and sharp kitchen knives is not a happy combination, or a worthwhile pursuit. At least it's not if you have this not so secret weapon at your disposal:
It's not known as "America's Favorite Pumpkin" for nothing
Photo: Chronica Domus
Yes, shockingly to me, here is a case where canned proves to be a better option than the rigmarole of making pur
ée from scratch. The contents are consistently smooth and firm (unlike my dismal soupy attempts), and most importantly they are flavorful. Why reinvent the wheel when you don't have to? Best of all, a fail-safe recipe is thoughtfully provided
right there on the label.
Now, if you too are tempted to make your own pumpkin
tarts pies, and should you decide to use this recipe, I shall disclose upfront that I've tinkered with the spice proportions. In my not-so-humble opinion, it makes quite an improvement in flavor to the final outcome. I believe the amount of cinnamon called for in the Libby's recipe (1 teaspoon) completely overpowers the other spices so I reduce the quantity by half, and introduce freshly grated nutmeg (about 1/2 teaspoon) as a substitute. This infuses the filling with a pleasantly subtle aroma and flavor that is difficult to describe but must be tried. I also insist on using whole cloves that I crush with the aid of my trusty mortar and pestle.
There is something quite satisfying about bashing the living daylights out of one's spices, to say nothing of the aroma that fills the kitchen air
Photo: Chronica Domus
It is this combination and proportion of fresh spices that sets my
tarts pies apart from the potpourri-smelling examples one so often encounters on supermarket shelves. At least that is what I've been told by those that have sampled them. Of course, homemade pastry is a must and I strongly encourage you too to make your own. I have
been using this recipe ever since I crossed the pond, and discovered it in Martha Stewart's Pies and Tarts cookbook, a copy of which was given to me by a friend who did not bake. Incidentally, the pastry recipe also works well for savory filled pies too, as the amount of sugar called for is imperceptible.
Ready to pop into the hot oven
Photo: Chronica Domus
I do hope that you too will consider skipping the awful supermarket pretenders and instead make a few
tarts pies for your Thanksgiving feast this year. If I can do it as a transplanted Brit, albeit with the help of Libby's, you can too.
With the addition of a little whipped cream, our pie was swiftly devoured as part
of our Sunday dinner last weekend
Photo: Chronica Domus
Tell me, do you serve pumpkin pie to your family and friends on Thanksgiving day, or do you have another favorite that makes an appearance at your table? And, for those of you that bake, do you opt for canned pumpkin pur
ée or make your own?
Nota bene: I am neither paid nor do I receive recompense in exchange for applauding products or services within my blog. I do so because I enjoy them. If you are a kindred spirit, you too enjoy recommending nice things to fellow good eggs.